Access the Samosa archives
Cameron should not forget the mood of the English in his defence of the Union

By Tim Montgomerie

February 24th 2012

David Cameron is in Scotland today. His spinners are keen to say that he’s not so much making the case against independence but, instead, the case for the continuation of the United Kingdom.

He previews his speech in an article for today’s Scotsman. The PM emphasises four big benefits for Scotland if it stays part of the UK:

  • Strength: “We’re stronger because together we count for more in the world, with a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council, real clout in Nato and Europe, and unique influence with allies all over the world.”
  • Security: “We’re safer, because in an increasingly dangerous world we have the fourth-largest defence budget on the planet, superb armed forces and anti-terrorist and security capabilities that stretch across the globe.”
  • Prosperity: “We’re richer, because inside the United Kingdom Scotland’s five million people are part of an economy of 60 million, the seventh-richest economy on the planet and one of the world’s biggest trading powers. Today, Scotland has a currency which takes into account the needs of the Scottish economy as well as the rest of the United Kingdom when setting interest rates and it can borrow at rates that are among the lowest in Europe.”
  • Solidarity: “The United Kingdom helps ensure fairness, too. Not just because we all benefit from being part of a properly-funded welfare system, with the resources to fund our pensions and healthcare needs, but because there is real solidarity in our United Kingdom. When any part of the United Kingdom suffers a setback, the rest of the country stands behind it. Whether it is floods in the West Country, severe weather in the north or the economic dislocation that has hit different parts at different times and in different ways we are there for each other.”

Alex Massie has written a thoughtful analysis of Mr Cameron’s arguments at The Spectator, which I recommend.

It is obviously right and important that David Cameron makes the case for the UK sticking together but he will know that he must take a back seat in the overall campaign. His Coalition’s most important role is to ensure…

I forget who wrote it but Cameron’s role is essentially the one of bad cop. He and Coalition ministers need to play hardball so that the terms and timing of the independence referendum are not dictated by the SNP. The campaign itself must then be fought by politicians who are popular in Scotland – Alistair Darling, Annabel Goldie and Charles Kennedy have been proposed by David Torrance.

Screen Shot 2012-02-16 at 08.00.24
Finally, however, let me mention an additional role for Cameron. If Scots feel the English are unhappy with the Union and unhappy with the constitutional settlement this could be a factor that could tip the referendum result towards independence. Who wants to be part of a Union with someone who doesn’t like you much? English and Welsh resentment at unfairnesses such as the Barnett formula and the way that Scottish MPs can vote on issues that only affect the English (but not the other way round) is currently far from boiling point. That might change, however, as the whole question of the future of the UK draws closer. One can easily imagine newspapers and politicians talking about ungrateful Scots and fleeced English regions. Cameron should nip this in the bud now by reviewing the Barnett formula and moving towards English votes for English laws. I fear he won’t.

 

Originally published by Conservative Home

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

thesamosa on Twitter

Why I’m urging black and Asian Brits to vote gu.com/p/47hjz

Education and mother tongue: By  Syed Mohammad Ali April 10 2015 While there are varied implementation hurdl... bit.ly/1CvJWWy

New post: Yemen: Don't bring the war to my home thesamosa.co.uk/2015/04/09/yem…

New post: UK: Reclaim internet from extremists thesamosa.co.uk/2015/04/09/uk-…

New post: Bangladeshi: Voice has been heard thesamosa.co.uk/2015/04/09/ban…

Can Ukraine save itself from Vladimir Putin and the oligarchs? gu.com/p/478em

Iran nuclear talks: Rouhani vows to abide by deal bbc.co.uk/news/world-mid…

مجھے بھی پی سی بی کا چیرمین بنادیا جائے! express.pk/story/343851/ via @Roznama_Express

Dara: the tale of two Islams hits the stage - Watch and share bit.ly/1zWKHuP fb.me/3OwSpyuU8

True story of Mughal emperor who built Taj Mahal makes London debut bit.ly/15LCRIu fb.me/20eWNndKB

Teachers Are Being Trolled Online - But Not By Who You Might Think huff.to/1ME2Jdh

What You Need To Know About Tonight's Election Debate huff.to/1ME7NhG

IS crisis: Parents of radicalised children 'not going to police' bbc.co.uk/news/uk-321480…

Global warming and drought are turning the Golden State brown gu.com/p/474x9

Telegraph - London play Dara dramatists historic Muslim struggle against fundamentalism - By Peter Tatchell - eepurl.com/bgqyqr

Shahid Nadeem, author of the amazing 'Dara' play to speak at Richmix #PeaceTalks on h// goo.gl/ju21AT

Saudi planes pound Yemeni capital in second night of bombing, witnesses say gu.com/p/473my