Access the Samosa archives
A culture shift in Britain

By Josiah Mortimer

May 19 2017

Progressive alliances are more than formal pacts: this is a culture shift

The final tally for the ‘progressive alliance’ is out, and on the face it, it looks (perhaps fittingly) more like unilateral disarmament than any real pact. It turns out there’s more to it than that though.

Only the Liberal Democrats have stood aside for anyone – the Greens in Caroline Lucas’ Brighton Pavilion, in exchange for the Greens standing down in neighbouring Tory-held Kemptown.

Green targets elsewhere have seen no such détentes. Bristol West, currently held by Labour’s Thangam Debbonaire, remains a three way Labour-Green-Lib Dem battle, with MEP Molly Scott Cato contesting it for the Green Party.

And in the Isle of Wight, where Green candidate Vix Lowthion came third last time after the Conservatives and UKIP, now appears to be the main challenge to the Tories. Given UKIP’s fall in support – and the fact the Greens came second in the local elections last week – Labour and the Lib Dems have come under pressure to back one progressive candidate. They have not succumbed.

But there’s a bigger picture here. Elections under First Past the Post are of course about where parties choose to target: which seats they bother putting resources in.

Progressive Alliance, the cross-party group set up by the think tank Compass, say the Liberal Democrats and Labour have privately agreed not to actively campaign in marginal constituencies against one another other, where they have the clearest opportunity to unseat the Conservatives.

One source told me that Labour are only putting serious resources into seats with majorities between 7,000 and 25,000. While that one may have to be taken with a pinch of salt, given the latest polling it would not prove a huge surprise.

Even where parties have stood candidates, it’s not all hand-to-hand combat. Yesterday, a quite startling announcement went unreported: the Lib Dem candidate for Bury North asked voters to back the Labour candidate – surely a move unprecedented in recent election history.

There, just 378 votes separate Labour and the Tories. So with the Greens choosing to step aside, Lib Dem Richard Baum’s decision to urge his Lib Dem voters to back Labour’s James Frith is quite something.

And of course, elections are about where activists go. Groups like Progressive Alliance are not alone in mobilising party activists to campaign for other parties in battleground constituencies. Best for Britain, Gina Miller’s pro-European campaign (which crowdfunded nearly £400,000 recently) and More United (which did the same – and raised similar amounts) are both putting their substantial resources into getting activists into key ‘progressive’ seats.

Finally, voters go off ‘signals’ from parties. We saw that in Richmond Park last year, when the Greens stood down, giving de facto backing to Lib Dem Sarah Olney’s bid to unseat Zac Goldsmith.

Despite Labour refusing to stand down there, voters took their signal off the Greens anyway – Labour voters got behind Olney too in order to take down the pro-Brexit Goldsmith.

The effect of the Greens standing down in 25 seats can’t be understated. This isn’t just about deals – clearly party leaderships never wanted them to happen officially. But it is about priorities – picking battles, being smart and, for the three main progressive parties, focusing on unseating Conservatives or keeping marginal Labour/Lib Dem MPs. The Scottish Greens standing in only 10 seats this election is another sign of that kind of pragmatic and principled strategising.

With a wide range of groups pushing this kind of informal working together, the effect is much larger than the headline stats. Kudos has to be given to the Greens for leading the way (although of course, it’s only a broken voting system that means parties feel obliged to stand aside in the first place…).

Over the next few days we will see several more official announcements on this front. Whatever the final tally of deals, or (less-measurable) targeting decisions, something has already changed this election.

Originally published by Left Foot Forward 

Leave a Comment

Comments are closed.

thesamosa on Twitter

Grenfell Tower survivors 'too scared to seek help' because of immigration status theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/j…

Brexit: May unveils 'fair and serious' offer on EU citizens bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politi…

Saudi king ousts nephew to name son as first in line to throne theguardian.com/world/2017/jun…

London fire: A tale of two tower blocks bbc.co.uk/news/uk-englan…

Trump admits for first time 'I am being investigated' over James Comey's firing theguardian.com/us-news/2017/j…

Election results 2017: May to finalise cabinet amid DUP talks bbc.co.uk/news/uk-402311…

Election 2017: Exit poll predicts Tories to be largest party bbc.co.uk/news/election-…

Anwar Akhtar, Manchester 4/4 talks on May 10th on Cities, Tolerance, Multi culturalism and why the Prevent... fb.me/1Z0yHdCXI

With only 6 days to go - here's our analysis of what might stop the #muslimvote politics.co.uk/comment-analys… @HKesvani

With only 6 days to go - here's our analysis of what might happen to the #muslimvote politics.co.uk/comment-analys… @mehdirhasan

With only 6 days to go - here's @aakhtar's analysis of what might happen to the #muslimvote politics.co.uk/comment-analys… @MrBrendanCox

Watch our Director @aakhtar talk about Cities, Tolerance, #Multiculturalism & why #prevent is failing vimeo.com/217813053 @AJEnglish

With only 6 days to go - here's @aakhtar's analysis of what might happen to the #muslimvote politics.co.uk/comment-analys… @hopenothate

Cities, Tolerance, Multiculturalism & why #prevent is failing vimeo.com/217813053 . @mendcommunity

With only 6 days to go - here's @aakhtar's analysis of what might happen to the #muslimvote #GE2017 politics.co.uk/comment-analys… @SalmaYaqoob