Is Veena Malik a threat to Islam? |
Thursday, 16 December 2010 15:33 |
By Shyema Sajjad Khan
How is it that religious leaders are ready to hurl accusations and profanities at celebrities on camera but are fearful of shunning terrorists or corrupt leaders in the same way? Perhaps because celebrities neither possess weapons and nor a public office, hence they remain easy targets.
Originally published by Dawn
This question has been asked several times on numerous public forums and television shows but time and time again we see actors, models and singers bearing the brunt of Muftis in a fix.
On Sunday night, the Indian reality show Bigg Boss was under discussion on a local television show where Mufti Abdul Qawi was forgetting his manners arguing with former Bigg Boss contender and television personality, Ali Saleem. The talk show host stirred the discussion in the direction of Veena Malik, who is still a contender on the Indian show. Apparently, Mufti sahib was very angry because Veena seems to be disrespecting Islam by behaving so irresponsibly in India on public television. What I don’t seem to understand is that how did this woman who got famous mimicking politicians and dancing between trees in Lollywood movies, become a representative of Islam?
She certainly did not enter the show as a Muslim contender. She was chosen for the show as a Pakistani celebrity (if you may) who became popular recently for playing an active role in making the cricket scandal further scandalous. I suppose it is okay for Veena to show her body in scanty silky saris and dance provocatively on local screens but the minute she starts showing that ‘immoral’ behviour in India, oh no, Islam is in danger!!
Ali Saleem, famous for his television persona Begum Nawazish Ali, mentioned the Hajj Scam, the corruption of our leaders, the silence of police on the face of torture and the unjustified killings which have become commonplace in our country but somehow all of that does not hold any weight to Veena getting comfy with an Indian (read: Hindu). Hats off to him for keeping his cool while the Mufti sahab accused him of “bay ghairthi, bay sharmi and bay hayai”. What a “mujrim” he is in this day and age, dressing up as a woman on screen.
So basically, Islam is under threat because of people like Veena who have joined the ranks of culprits such as suicide bombers who kill dozens by the day in the name of religion. But wait – while being put on the spot upon the insistence of Ali Saleem, the Mufti did condemn suicide bombers – so I suppose the religious leaders have done their duty.
I don’t think I’m giving enough credit to the show’s host here. By inviting a conservative Mufti and a controversially liberal celebrity to debate, the host already knew what the outcome would be: a mockery of both the guests. How would the show get its ratings and popularity without an angry religious scholar and a controversial celebrity attacking each other on screen?
Farzana Bari, a human rights activist, who was also invited to the debate, pointed out that neither has she nor Mufti Abdul Qawi seen the programme, and nor could they see the scandalous clips playing on the screen at the time of the debate. And the clips that were playing on screen were carefully chosen to show Veena at her best, or worst – but then again, nothing sensationalises better than the same clips shown over and over again.
But all of that didn’t seem to be important. What was important was that a Pakistani actress was causing the nation to hang its head in shame! As if being in the limelight for terrorism, honour killings, fake degrees, corrupt leaders and Baitullah Mehsud wasn’t enough, now we have Veena Malik who also wants to destroy the identity of Pakistan. The charged-up youth and ever-ready-to-protest religious parties must get their placards ready now – this is after all a matter of national and religious identity and Veena’s agenda must be destroyed! |
Last Updated on Thursday, 16 December 2010 15:38 |
Also, why are Pakistanis so hung up on the way a woman dresses? It seems Pakistanis feel justified to dismiss and even physically and verbally attack any woman who does not follow the patriarchal rules of dress. Are Pakistani men so shallow that the sight of a woman's hair or shoulders would drive them to sexual insanity? What do you mean to say about your own people? Why is there so much fear of women rising to any kind of stardom or having a voice.
I particularly do not follow celebs but I would be stupid to think that millions around the world do not. This is an untapped mechanism to win the hearts of the world for Pakistanis. If there are more Veena Maliks, please bring them to limelight, please grow all the arts and entertainment industries in Pakistanis, and then you will see how the world starts to love you. Sorry if you do not like this reality, but that's the game. Pakistan has to work to get the world's attention and support in all ways, political and otherwise. And it's not like your Zardari president has really done that great in the political department. The point is just like other nations have different sources for attracting and winning over people, Pakistan needs to have the same.
And please people it is not about showing your body. Can we please get over this already. I agree with earlier point that it doesnt matter what a woman wears, all women deserve respect. It seems only Pakistanis have a hang-up on issues of clothing, when the rest of the world really doesnt care!!!! Get over it people and learn to love and respect all human beings, and yes, that includes women.
It is not about copying India or America, it is about understanding the way it works. You cannot force people to like you, you have to make them relate to you and you have to be open to connecting as human beings. All humans love music, laughter, movies and so on. This is the way to connect with audiences of the world. WHen they see Pakistani in diverse roles through our own produced movies and songs than they will not have to only rely on western media's images of us as terrorits and wife beaters. Look at the images of Pakistani women, they are all images of beaten down covered up women who seem like from stone ages, no one in America is going to relate to that and justify it, but when they see there is diversity in Pakistani people, that we too are human through our movies, songs, fashion, etc then we can actually start a discussion. Right now all Americans and the world see are people who are terrorists and heartless killers. This is why we did not have as much donations to our earthquake and floods as did Tsunami.
And yes, from what I have seen of Veena Malik, I do think she carries herself with grace and charm. It is nice to see this in a Pakistani woman as it diversifies the image of what Pakistani are and can be.
Ahmad -Because your mind and exposure to the world is so narrow, you equate any woman not wearing a burka to a prostitute who is to be hated. First of all, all women need to be loved and respected for being human beings! When you humiliate your own women in front of the world, absolutely no one will have respect for you, or your homeland of Kashmir!
We need change! We need it now! We are sick of religious extremists and even the religious so called moderates dominating the country's image. They also end up speaking for all Muslims and Pakistanis around the world. Dictators and so called Pakistani political leaders have done nothing and will do nothing. We need to build our people up to take over the country's image by other means.
I love Veena Malik, the country should do everything they can to promote her. We need a balanced image of Pakistan out there and to heck with the mullahs and their cheap mentality. I also love Ms Tahmena Bokhari, what a shining star of a person she is. All of Pakistan could learn from such grace.
Trying to portray only one kind of woman in media is ridiculous and misleading to say the least. Women like Veena Malik to me are the pride of Pakistan. It is the actresses, music and so on that are influencing the young and through entertainment opening the minds of the world to the diversity and beauty of Pakistan. I do believe women like Tahmena and Veena and others who take a stand and go against the grain in such creative ways could threaten this religious radicalism, which to me is a great thing. Look at India and America, how they have managed to win the hearts and minds of people around the world, not due to their politics or policies, but despite their politics and unjust policies, they have won people through their music, media and movie stars, celebs and famous personalities.